Noel Tata on Friday again sought video recordings of the Sept 3 Tata Sons nomination and remuneration (NRC) meeting and the Sept 17 Tata Sons board meeting that culminated in N Chandrasekaran‘s reappointment as chairman. The company had earlier rejected his demand, saying it was not legally required to share or retain recordings of in-person meetings with directors.The Tata Trusts chairman, who is also a Tata Sons director, has now asked the company to “preserve” the recordings of both the NRC meeting and the board meeting. In a seven-page letter dated Nov 20 to company secretary Suprakash Mukhopadhyay, copied to all directors, he sought written responses by Nov 25, a day before the Tata Sons board meets.

Noel argued that directors were entitled to inspect the company’s electronic records and that Article 129 of Tata Sons’ Articles of Association (AoA) did not exclude such access. He warned that any deletion or alteration after Sept 18, when he first sought preservation, would amount to “deliberate destruction of evidence” and offered to inspect the recordings at Bombay House, Tata Group’s headquarters, in the presence of an adviser.Noel again disputed the minutes of the Sept 17 board meeting and reiterated that no resolution on Chandrasekaran’s reappointment for a third term had been validly passed under Articles 118 and 121 of the AoA.While Tata Sons had listed a “debrief from the NRC” as an agenda item for the Sept 17 board meeting, Noel maintained that the agenda did not provide for a resolution on Chandrasekaran’s reappointment, which was nevertheless taken up. He also contended that the NRC minutes circulated to him were only a draft and did not bear the signatures of committee members.The final minutes of the Sept 17 board meeting will come up for approval at the Tata Sons board’s Nov 26 meeting, where directors can either approve them or record their objections.Noel asked that the board consider his objections before finalising the minutes.He said the reappointment required the affirmative vote of a majority of the Trusts’ directors present at the Sept 17 meeting. One of the two voted in favour and the other against. Noel disputed the use of the chairman’s casting vote to break the tie, arguing that the provision did not authorise it.Noel also renewed his objection to Tata Sons’ filing with the Registrar of Companies stating that Chandrasekaran was reappointed for another five years, a step he says was never validly taken.He renewed his conflict-of-interest objection over the business relationship between TVS Motor Co, associated with Venu Srinivasan, and Hanno One Warehousing, a company linked to members of Chandrasekaran’s family.Noel contended that Srinivasan, a Tata Trusts trustee and Tata Sons director, should have recused himself from the NRC proceedings that recommended Chandrasekaran for a third term. Srinivasan also voted for the reappointment at the Sept 17 board meeting. Tata Sons previously rejected the conflict-of-interest argument, saying Hanno One has no transactions with Tata Sons or any Tata group entity. It maintained that a contract awarded by TVS Motor to a company in which Chandrasekaran’s family has a disclosed interest does not create a conflict with Tata Sons. Noel said that response missed the point. The issue, he said, was whether directors involved in evaluating the executive chairman and considering his reappointment could exercise independent judgement.Noel also questioned Tata Sons’ Oct 6 letter to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), in which the company said it intended to comply with the regulator’s norms and was keen to take steps towards doing so. He said the letter had neither been shown to him nor placed before the board before it was sent. He disputed the company’s interpretation that the Sept 17 board meeting had authorised it to pursue a listing, saying directors had agreed only to explore alternatives and seek guidance from RBI. RBI replied on Nov 16, telling Tata Sons to comply with its rules, including the requirement to list.He also asked that the Trusts’ Sept 28 merger proposal, which he said would let Tata Sons cease to be classified as a non-banking financial company without a listing, be circulated to directors ahead of the Nov 26 meeting, along with management’s assessment of it and the legal advice received. He asked Tata Sons to send RBI nothing beyond an acknowledgement, take no steps towards a listing and make no changes to its AoA or capital structure until the board decided how to proceed.

✍️ Vikrant Kharwar
Vikrant Kharwar is the Founder and Editor of News Us Media. He writes about trending news, sports, entertainment, technology, and viral stories. His goal is to make news simple, informative, and easy to understand for readers across the United States and around the world.